November 22, 2017

Why Is My Home Insured For More Than It’s Worth?

Image of the outside of a beautiful home.

My home is worth $275,000. Why does my insurance company want me to insure it for $375,000?

This is probably the most frequently asked question among our Homeowners Policy clients today. We will usually respond with…“and be glad that it is, let me show you why.”

Comparing market or real estate value of a home and replacement cost of a home is like comparing apples and oranges. Market value is the price for which you could sell your home. Market value takes into consideration land value, neighborhood, comparable sales, and more. Replacement or reconstruction cost is the amount of money it would take to rebuild your home, with like kind and quality, at today’s costs. Replacement cost reflects the cost for building materials, code compliance, demolition, construction labor, and more.

In the current economy, many people are under the assumption that construction costs have reduced as much as property values. This is simply not the case. The fact of the matter is, today, you can buy an existing home for much less money than it would cost to build that very same home. Although you may hear from a friend that they got someone to do some work for “super cheap,” this is the exception to the rule. Contractors’ overhead hasn’t reduced much, and cost for building materials hasn’t decreased dramatically either. Contractors are just like everyone else, they need to put food on the table, and I don’t know many non-profit construction companies out there.

The amount of coverage you need should be based on the true reconstruction costs of your home, regardless of current market value.